Federal Appeals Court Rules that ADA Does Not Apply to Netflix Captioning
Updated: January 4, 2018
A ruling by the United States federal appeals court last week concluded that the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) does not apply to Netflix.
The appeal responded to a 2011 class action lawsuit filed by Donald Cullen, a deaf Netflix viewer, who claimed that Netflix was breaking anti-discrimination law by failing to provide adequate closed captioning on its online streaming videos. The judge threw that lawsuit out, prompting an appeal. Three judges of the 9th Circuit court supported that decision, reasoning that because Netflix is “not connected to any actual, physical place,” it cannot be considered a place of public accommodation and therefore is not subject to the ADA.
The ruling on this case contradicts a 2010 lawsuit brought against Netflix by the National Association for the Deaf, which also claimed a breach of the ADA for lack of captioning online video. Netflix settled that case out of court, covering over $750K in legal fees for the NAD. Netflix also agreed to provide closed captioning on its video library by the end of 2014.
It’s important to note that the Cullen v. Netflix ruling is unpublished, meaning it is not intended to be considered legal precedent. This ruling comes on the heels of another lawsuit that concerns web accessibility and captioning of online video by Harvard and MIT.
Study Highlights: Implementation of and Solutions for Closed Captioning in US Institutions of Higher Education
Most colleges and universities in the US are legally required to provide closed captioning on many of their videos. Despite the laws, many institutions of higher education struggle to implement closed captioning practices. The national research study, Implementation of and Solutions for…
The Growing Population with Hearing Loss
We are quite the noisy population. Everywhere we go, sound is always surrounding us. Whether it’s police sirens passing by, or music through our headphones on our way to work, there is always background noise. Over 5% of the world’s population –…
3Play Media’s Top 10 Blog Posts of 2017
It’s that time of year again! Looking back on the blog posts from last year that peaked our readers’ interests the most helps everyone imagine what to expect in the new year. We would also like to take this opportunity to thank…