Why YouTube Videos with Auto-Captions May Be Inaccessible
Updated: February 2, 2021
With 300 hours of video uploaded to YouTube every minute, and 1,300,000,000 users, it sounds quite impressive that the video distribution platform is now boasting over 1 billion captioned videos on their site. However, when you take a closer look at their captioned videos, you’ll notice that they’re not always accurate.
A History of Automatic Captions at YouTube
In 2006 YouTube began encouraging content creators posting to their site to add captions and subtitles to their videos to increase accessibility. A mere three years later, the Google-owned company released their Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) tool to make captioning videos on their site a reality. Despite improvements to their ASR tool, automatically generated captions realistically average 60-70% accuracy, which means that 1 in 3 words are incorrect. Although this accuracy rate can be improved with good audio quality and simple content, it also worsens when there is background noise, accents, or multi-syllable words. All in all, automatically generated captions are not sufficient when it comes to accessibility.
Why Automatic Captions Are Not Accessible
Studies have shown that even 95% accuracy is sometimes insufficient for accurately conveying complex material. In an average sentence of 8 words, a 95% word accuracy rate means there will be an error on average every 2.5 sentences.
Furthermore, ASR technology is prone to fail on the small “function” words that are crucial in conveying meaning in speech. Take a look at the below sentences:
“I didn’t want to do that exercise.” vs. “I did want to do that exercise.”
This example is a very common ASR error, and although a seemingly small one, the meaning of the sentence is actually completely reversed. It is very rare for a human editor to make such a mistake, as they’re able to use context to help identify and choose the correct word.
How to Add Accurate Captions to YouTube Videos
If you’re planning to add captions to your YouTube videos, don’t be discouraged! There are a few ways to improve the accuracy of closed-captions on your online content.
- From the rough automatic captions that YouTube creates, you can create your own captions the DIY way or enlist the help of your viewers for crowdsourced captions and subtitle translation.
- The fastest, easiest way to get accurate captions is to hire a professional closed captioning company. This is highly recommended if you need to caption YouTube videos at scale, since you can automate your captioning workflow.
At 3Play Media, we use a 3-step process which includes a combination of ASR and human cleanup. Our advanced technology enables our competitive prices, and our multi-step quality assurance measures ensure we deliver premium quality captions, subtitles, and transcripts far more efficiently than traditional methods.
Our average measured accuracy is 99.6%, and we guarantee over 99%, even in cases of poor audio quality, multiple speakers, difficult content, and accents. Our staff of more than 1,000 transcriptionists gives us the flexibility to assign complex or technical content to transcriptionists with a discipline-specific expertise or a familiarity with a certain accent, enabling us to process a broad range of complex content.
However you choose to get your caption file, uploading it to YouTube is a breeze. Download our free step-by-step guide to learn how now!
How to Handle Live Closed Captioning – and the Challenges
Technological innovation has paved a new way to conduct business, education, and life in general – particularly in a world forced to adapt to virtual substitutes during the pandemic. Most of the time, the technology we use is very helpful. For example,…
Transcribing Oral Histories with 3Play Media
History can be told in many ways, but one of the most impactful methods is through oral history. Oral history is a technique for preserving historical information through recorded interviews. In a typical oral history, an interviewer questions an interviewee and records…
How to Scale Live Closed Captioning: 6 Top Tips
As live video content continues to grow in popularity, most video & social media platforms have enabled live streaming features due to the sheer number of people tuning into live streams. In 2019 alone, internet users watched a staggering 1.1 billion hours of…